I was not aware of this rule... and it seems it would be impossible to enforce to me. So 10 villagers have to be killed immediately if a member either quits or is kicked from an island?
As for the team aspect, it is also not right to penalize those that are able and desire to play together. Is is any more fair for 10 players to only have 10 villagers?
Skyblock will never be balanced imho as there are way too many variables. Instead of mobs per member, it should always be per island, again in my humble opinion. The same for redstone, hoppers, signs, chests, or anything else... per island. All members would share that way and be a better balance for all.

 

Thank you for that information... good to know. So it is like chests and signs, you try to place a villager and it says no and does not take an egg and I assume they will not breed after the limit is made.
That makes sense so that if a member leaves, the code would just kill the villagers.

 

Please excuse any confusion I might have, but villagers are not something I am very familiar with yet. I am sure that as I grow up I will understand more about what you are saying :p
For now, I think it is wise for all mobs and limits to be per island and not just a select few here and there. Even the 10k per 10 level is per island for the very same reason.
One final question - did you have a per island limit you would feel is more reasonable? If so, it would be awesome to add that to your suggestion.

 

with island sizes like we have on here you should be able to cover the outer edges of the island with 16 iron farms respecting the minimum distance you have to have between them. then you can stack them about 4 times that would be 64 farms per island AT LEAST (you can still put up some on the inner part of the island but thats inconvenient when it comes to other farms) somehow its pointless to put them up in that layout unless you got the manpower to have all the chunks loaded at all times (one of the reasons i initially questioned the island sizes ^^)

 

I believe there is a suggestion that limits should be the same per island.. I feel like that should be taken seriously...

I don’t think advantages should be given for teams over individuals. Granted awards are split over teams, however that is their choice and allows them to level faster. I don’t think individuals should be at an even more disadvantage. Limits should be the same for everyone and by that I mean all limits..

Just my thoughts.

 

+1 I would say give everyone like 25, the solos have enough and the teams can share.

 

25 is way too little for skyblock imo, It should be unlimited or at least a very high amount.

But I do agree with this post in general.

 

Villager limits have been changed.
Prior to this change it was 10 per player, and then increased to 25 per player.

We have now changed this to be island based. Teams can no longer increase their villager limit to be higher than a solo player.
The new island limit for everyone is 100 villagers.

 

Bigger update can be found here:
https://www.ecocitycraft.com/forum/threads/skyblock-changing-entity-limits.175680/

EVEN MORE LIMIT CHANGES :D