Denied New spawn

Spawn is kind of fun though-I once found four netherstars in it. I find it fun to go around and see the history of ECC in the form of building, but I’m weird like that. I would hate for spawn to go away, but I do admit that the original spawn place is a bit too much. (I.E. the place with the portals, but to be honest, I’m just sensitive to bright objects)

 

Comes back after months of inactivity and shits on the new spawn.. get out of here dude. Lets see your new design? I am very curious how it turned out..

 

To clarify more, I think spawn is extremely fun to go around and overall just see how gorgeous it is. That’s the first things some builders do, beside the tutorial. And you don’t need fly to see things-it’s spawn, mostly for portal use. So why are we dissing it? Even if this gets accepted, who is going to want to spend their time making a huge spawn that will fit each and every persons needs and wants? The player base is already dead. No offense y’all, but maybe it’s not spawn that’s affecting our community.........

 

@jmichael214 I'm not going to quote the post because its long, so here's your tag.

I think what you said was a little bit harsh. Nobody was trying to make it seem like the work you put into the spawn was nothing. I know how much work you put into that spawn. I've been at the centre of a lot of big spawn projects and they do take weeks to do, so don't think I'm coming at this without some experience. A lot of what was said is valid, even if some of the comments were a tad insensitive. The spawn you've created is truly magnificent, but I think one of the main problems is it's just too big. This, of course, isn't exactly your fault. It won the competition fair and square and we are truly better off with your new spawn than what we had prior. But if we could perhaps revamp a few parts of it, namely the shop, I think it would be a whole lot better. There's a lot of whats good with your spawn so I don't want you to take any offence personally to whatever's being said in this thread, its mostly going to be constructive criticism.
I felt like I needed to say this because as a builder myself (not nearly as good as you), I understand sometimes you don't like your work being criticised by people who clearly don't know the kind of work goes into it, and you looked a little salty, so don't mind me saying this .

 

Alright then rebuild the shop? Rebuild what you want changed and make it better! I am sure you would have better luck.

 

World edit mirroring isn't hard considering the pretty linear and somewhat blocky/squarish design of most of the spawn structures. Helped DD build her spawn with world edit and I've done a number of other personal projects as well as helped with other friends' builds so I don't see how this reveals a lack of knowledge as I'm quite familiar with both building and world edit but you're entitled to your own opinion.

I apologize for offending you and underestimating the work you put into your spawn, was not looking to attack you personally at all, but frankly the structures in spawn don't look difficult to mirror at all with the use of world edit hence why I gave my opinion. The effort you've put into the spawn hasn't gone unnoticed and I as well as many other players appreciate your commitment to the server.

 

Oh, I was totally salty. Worldedit, my butt.

 

Lmao world editing something like that would be so irritating i'd just build it by hand anyway

 

I don't know what that is, let alone how to do it. I'm really pretty inept when it comes to technology.

 

when you build half of your build, copy it, then paste it after you've reversed it on the other side.

 

What about the mod office
+1 If we can put a mod office in the next spawn.

 

The purpose of suggestions is to request that something be changed, not asking to change it by yourself. Seems quite counter-intuitive to tell people to have ready-made solutions before people even give enough feedback or it's even accepted. I think it's a terrible argument to tell people "well why don't you do it then!" That's like saying if you don't like how a country is run, go for president. It's perfectly reasonable to ask for change, and it's completely unreasonable to ask a person to have a solution ready especially when if they are incapable of it, because as jmichael said himself, most exceptional builders would give up halfway and ask why they started in the first place. If this suggestion were accepted and another competition implemented, there would be incentive to participate, and there would be multiple designs to choose from different people that voluntarily built spawns. When eekelmo suggested a new spawn, which became the current spawn today, would you have told him to have a new one built already? Who cares if a person comes back after months - in my opinion that just means they notice the problems quicker because they haven't been around enough to become sensitized to the change. You don't need to be rude simply because a person suggests a change.

 

+1

I am all for innovation and improving the quality of the spawn area.
As @GeorgiaMC stated above, the current spawn is inaccessible and confusing for new players. Even though lots of effort and time was put into developing the spawn area, I'm completely confident in the fact that those who want to pitch in, will find some way to help. Even if it is one builder, or a group of people building and crowdsourcing their ideas, something as big as making the spawn area more efficient should be focused in on sooner rather than later. Whether it takes a short or long while to plan and build, I think that it is a worthy investment of time.
Something smaller, accessible, more homey, and eye-catching would be neat!

 

...how can a suggestion even be accepted if there isn't a solution? If there isn't a solution proposed than there isn't even a way to implement the suggestion and it can't be accepted. Sure, even if it isn't "ready-made" it still needs to have some thought. "I don't like this" isn't helpful, "this would be better" is.

Getting involved in the process is exactly what you should do though. And in the subject, outside of binary options, any sort of movement needs an actual goal. "Not this" isn't a goal when there's no alternative proposed!

I could support this suggestion because spawn could be better. However spawn could always be better, and agreeing to change it before knowing what I'm agreeing to change it to is as easily a step backward as it is one forward.


As an aside I find it hilarious everyone is complaining it's "confusing for new players"... The only bad part is the server shops which new players literally can't navigate right off the bat even if they want to since they have no money. Everything else consists of walking through giant portals that are clearly labelled.

 

I guess we are all surprised that this is the first thing you do when you came back to ECC. (In forums, at least) But the problem is going to be, as I said in one of my posts, finding someone to do the build. And the staff is already swamped with work...Cough skyblock Cough

 

Lol.

 

Concerning your first point, I was just surprised this was the first thing you did. Not that it’s bad or wrong, and I just assume you are very dedicated about ECC and the quality of playing. I haven’t seen much of that lately! So kudos to you!!
As for your second point, I do believe we can all make a new spawn together, which would be fun. And I agree, @jmichael214 should have that opportunity. The player base may be dying, but I do think that a new spawn project would be fun and increase player count. I’m just worried something is going to happen, like a new game mode, ect that will cause everyone to loose focus. But I do trust that someone like you could organize it! I’m just worried about what may happen.