If you're taking a loan to get it, you should get the melon sword since it'll make you decent money without fly.

 

I wouldn't suggest taking huge loans at all.

 

why not both?

 

I would definitely get fly. Best investment ever. It makes building and getting around so much easier.

 

you won't know how you managed to survive without fly if you get it

 

I highly suggest against this. I can make up to 15k an hour with a good farm and a Melon Sword. It would not take you long to make back the money needed for a loan, and the money for fly can be made rather fast as well. My vote is for the Sword.

 

You can also make 15k an hour on pumpkins if you know how to do it right.

 

But pumpkins require a large farm. With a melon sword you need a much smaller farm because it takes more time to harvest. I would personally get a melon sword, but I already have fly so I may not be the most reliable person in that aspect.

 

Once you get fly you have nothing better to do on this server then fly arround when you get bored.

 

Yeah, but only in a really good hour. If its a laggy hour then.... No money 4 you!

I'm going to say a melon sword. With a melon sword not only do you have a good income but if you desire you can sell the sword and get fly. You can't sell the fly donation if you change your mind.

 

I'm only a resident but I would get melon sword and then fly. The melon sword will pay for the fly.