I've got a variety of armors (leath -> gold), an enchanted book, a lot of enchanted tools/fishing poles, every fish... and yeah, some odd things like tripwire hooks and potions that don't harm me.

 

Fish.. That's all I've gotten.

 

I've gotten tripwire hooks, rotten flesh, a bone, and now a lily pad :p.

 

Lapis, Tripwire Hooks, Lily Pads, Bones, Armor (Gold/Leather), Emchanted/Plain Bows, Tools (Stone/Wooden/Iron), Swords, Fish, Plain Poles, Water Bottles, Empty Bowls, & Ink Sacs.

No Enchanted Books :(
No Enchanted Poles :(

I am so waiting for my first enchanted book via fishing. :rolleyes:

 

I've gotten some bows and some wooden/stone tools :/

 

OMGWHATISTHAT OMGOMGOMG

IT'S TNT!! RUN!

 

fish, unb3 rods and a prot4 punch2 book oo

 

ive caught tnt

 

I managed to catch a diamond yesterday... o.o

 

I caught a unbreaking 3, fire protection 2, sharp 2 book but not a single fish yet so...

 

15 regular fish, 5 salmon, 3 puffer fish, a punch 1 ebook and several lit pieces of tnt. I also caught a almost dead wooden hoe.

 

I caught my first ebook. It was Lure II, Bane II, Knockback II.

I find it funny that there is nothing that can use all three. Choice choices.

 

Fish. Nothing special yet

 

Caught an Unbreaking III book, which got anviled onto my rod.

 

Time to start fishing, lol

 

How much are the rare fish worth?

 

I'd expect quite a bit.
They are rare, aren't they?
That is, they will be until there are like, thousands on the server.