Denied [All Main Servers Suggestion] Scavenger Feature

Probably hard to do and we dont need more features so -1

 

-1 it could be me, but I don't see the need for this on this specific server

 

I believe you're more so meaning a sort of "Magnet" effect, and while I do love this for my singleplayer worlds to have this effect equipped, I don't want to see this on ECC for a few reasons.

-1 from me.

 

-1 95% sure this would create a dupe or an extremely powerful autofarm. You know what I’m talking about john

 

+1 & -1

On the one hand i can see the appeal of a feature like this, and personally i would almost instantly buy it, since it would be more than a little useful in for instance eff7 mining. Not going to lie, i've thought of this exact feature a couple of times before...

... However, the implementation of it would likely be a headache to say the least, and i don't feel comfortable giving my support to something like this without knowing the full potential implications of it. I doubt that it would suddenly create a major dupe that wouldn't already be available, like you already said, but still...

If there is a relatively easy way to implement it, and it wouldn't create major problems for the server, absolutely +1.
Otherwise, -1.

 

Would you care to elaborate on the reasons?
Gotta be honest, i'm kind of curious now.

 

I mean, for starters it basically makes ECC Melon Swords act like Magic Melon Swords, assuming this distance can contain the drops. It's a great thing, and although I'd love it seeing as I have an ECC Msword but not a Magic Msword, it's not really feasible unless something changed.

 

The magic melonsword automatically puts melons in your inventory. The primary problem with the ECC melonsword is that if you go full speed, you will pick up virtually no melons and they will land on the ground and despawn, as you are going too fast for them to end up in your inventory. As a result you either have to stutter while farming (starting + stopping, repeat) or just farm at a slow speed. The main allure of the magic msword is the fact that it automatically puts items in your inventory, so this feature would nullify that, assuming that the feature extends to a reasonable distance.

 

I' not sure it should be necessarily something that is a paid feature, or for all pickups - I'll leave that up to the owners to decide, but I would however like to see a pickup or magnetism range increased for crops on a magic hoe. Maybe a white list for certain crops like done for the player placed ores with the magic pick? As it is right now when you harvest crops, a fair amount will get thrown 1-2 blocks out of range of the pickup range behind you causing a bit of back tracking.

 

Don't currently own a magic sword, but this sounds like a good feature/solution for the magic hoe to get around this pickup range issue (putting crops in inventory automatically)?

 

From what I hear, it already makes far too much money for another buff to really be within reason.

 

No. You seem to not understand. Fishing doesn't place them in your inventory in the same way. Imagine you were fishing while moving - the fish would land behind you, right? Now imagine that you right click and the fish suddenly appears in your inventory, without flying through the air or anything.

What magic melon swords do is it places the block literally in your inventory - no entities drop on the ground, period, as I understand it. Magic melon swords exist so that people don't "have to double back in case any items are left behind" - that is its entire allure, and its entire value. This feature would eliminate that value to a significant extent if implemented.
The most popular server in Minecraft, not saying its name, has a Skyblock mode where there is a custom enchantment known as "telekinesis" - as far as I am aware, ours is essentially the same thing. Feel free to google it. Go to YouTube and type "skyblock telekinesis" and watch the first video.

I am fully aware of your intentions with the feature. It's something people have wanted for a very long time. You don't seem to be understanding what I am saying, however.

 

I agree while it would be nice, for instant placement into your inventory would likely be to big of a buff. Thats why i was thinking of the magnetism or a range increase for normal pickup being a possible solution to pick up the stuff that some times gets yeeted. They could tie it to herbalism skill for crops or something like +1 blocks for every 500 skill levels (+2 at cap of 1k).

 

I wouldn't mind it being tied to an McMMO skill too much. Still, it seems overpowered, and I'm not aware that tying it to an McMMO skill is even possible.

 

You'd understand the difference if you ever used one. It's not as simple as "oh it gets dropped into your inventory instead of picked up". You don't understand how many melons are lost to farming at speed 10 if it is not magic.