Okay 1 question, I like the idea, but those commands don’t remember what they were. So mud can’t go back to both of them. It would have to go back to a specific chosen one regardless of what it was originally

 

+0 leaning -1. I can see the appeal with concrete on a very small scale, but at the same time, how many times are you running /soak all with powder in your inventory that you don’t want soaked?

For the mud to the various dirts, not only is this suggesting that /desoak on mud gives one of three possibilities, the three possibilities are so common, it basically takes longer to run the command than it takes to collect the items.

IMO, /soak is such a niche command that these “errors” aren’t that common, and happen for items that aren’t valuable/hard to reobtian. Only reason it isn’t a pure -1 is I see validity in only the concrete, but at the same time, I wonder if we can put that in another command (we already have a lot of commands like /smelt, /strip, /oxidize, etc. I hate adding more).