Denied [Main City Server Suggestion] Add Unbreaking to all star tools

+1

 

+1 for Unbreaking 3
-1 for anything higher

 

+1
I think higher levels of Unbreaking could work but especially for the shovel it seems like it would be a nice addition.

 

I like the mininalism and I have commands++ makes unbreaking irrelevant. Why have irrelevant enchantments which I can't remove added instead of giving people the chance to add them if they wish.

 

But for those who don't have commands++, having unbreaking on it will help them. Even if you didn't want unbreaking on it, it's not like it gets in your way...

 

Yeah but it costs them what, a few thousand to get an unbreaking book/enchant? A trivial amount compared to the tool which is 7 figures.

So ultimately this is just a matter of preference - and at that rate, why force one option on everyone?

 

This suggestion also talks about higher levels on unbreaking besides 3, and I understand what you're saying. I'm just looking at this from the perspective that for those who want unbreaking, it will be helpful for them and for those for who it doesn't really matter or don't really want it, it makes no difference to them or to how the tool works. It may be a matter of preference, but would anyone say "I'm not going to buy this tool now because it has unbreaking on it"? I don't think they would. So it's either beneficial or irrelevant but never detrimental, that's why I think this suggestion is a good idea. Also like I said I wouldn't mind having higher unbreaking levels on tools such as the shovel, though it could realistically be used on any tool and considered a nice bonus for it being a star tool.

 

Honestly, it should be Unb3 or not at all. Auto Repair is a thing, and getting ereps is not hard

 

But it would be nicer if there was more time between having to get ereps

 

If you can afford a star tool you can afford commands+, it's literally half the price of a star tool.

 

After reading the entire conversation above, I'm going to lean towards not adding unbreaking to all star tools.
It would work against our erepair market as well, and some people make money off that.